Sarpino’s Discontinued Menu Items

Several Sarpino’s Singapore pizzas and one dessert have quietly left the menu, led by The Godfather, Satay Chicken and the Smores Dessert Pizza. This Sarpino’s discontinued menu items guide lists what disappeared, the evidence for each one, and the closest current swap for every favourite. If you want the full current range first, start with the Sarpino’s menu hub, then come back here for the ones that are gone.

Which Sarpino’s menu items have been discontinued in Singapore?

The table below splits the list by how strong the evidence is. The top four come straight from Sarpino’s own food menu archive, so we’re confident they were real menu items. The rest come from older guides and a social post, so treat them as likely gone rather than certain. Every item here is missing from the current Singapore menu, which lists 40 items across classic, gourmet and specialty pizzas, sides, desserts and drinks.

One honest caveat before you go further: absence from the current menu is strong evidence, but it isn’t the same as a company announcement. A dish could still appear at a single outlet or return as a special, so if one of these is the reason you’re ordering, check with the outlet first.

The Godfather and Satay Chicken lead the list

The Godfather was the meatiest of the four archive pizzas, with pepperoni and spicy fennel beef sausage over peppers and mozzarella. Satay Chicken was the local twist, with sweet and smoky satay marinated chicken on peanut sauce, a flavour built for Singapore tastes. Both sat in the gourmet section of the older archive menu, and neither appears among the six gourmet pizzas on the current menu, which now runs Boston Supreme, Classico Italiano, Midnight Express, New York Deli, Tropical Hawaiian and Chicken Alfredo.

The dessert pizza that vanished too

The Smores Dessert Pizza is the only dessert on the discontinued list, and it comes with a warning label. The official archive lists it at RM13.80, in ringgit, which points to a Malaysian menu page rather than a Singapore one. The Singapore dessert list today is just two items, chocolate lava cake and tiramisu, both at S$8.90, so there’s no dessert pizza on sale here either way. If you remember it from Singapore, it may have been a short run, and the lava cake is the closest thing left.

Limited time specials that ran their course

Omni-Rendang Pizza was never a permanent item. It showed up in a June 2021 social post as a meat-free special, and limited specials end by design. The same goes for Gourmet Smoked Salmon and Le Resistance, which a 2022 HalalTrip guide named as popular gourmet specials at the time. When a special disappears, it usually means its run ended, not that customers rejected it, so don’t read a failure into these three.

Why did Sarpino’s remove these items from the menu?

Sarpino’s hasn’t said, and that’s worth stating plainly rather than guessing a reason and dressing it up as fact. What we can say is that menus rotate for a few usual reasons: slow sellers get cut, kitchen space gets freed for new items, and local specials like Satay Chicken get tested for a season and then dropped. Limited specials are the clearest case, since they end on schedule by design. The rest look like normal rotation, with the gourmet range slimmed to six pizzas and the specialty range to six as well.

One pattern stands out. The current menu leans on proven sellers: every classic pizza costs S$23.90, every gourmet pizza S$27.90, and every specialty pizza S$25.90. A pizza that needs a special sauce or a topping nobody else uses costs more to keep, so it gets dropped first when the menu tightens. That’s the most likely story for Satay Chicken and its peanut sauce, and for Tandoori Chicken with its own marinade.

What replaced the discontinued Sarpino’s items?

Nothing replaced them one for one, but the current menu covers the same flavours well enough. The table below pairs each lost item with the closest current pizza and its verified price, so you can order the nearest match without hunting through the full menu. For the full ranked list of what sells now, the Sarpino’s menu ranked guide is the better place to browse.

If heat was the point, Midnight Express at S$27.90 is your best bet, since it carries chilli, jalapeno and spicy beef across the whole pizza. If it was the local flavour you miss, Teriyaki Chicken at S$23.90 is the only Asian style chicken pizza left, and it costs less than the gourmet range too. For the full list of current best sellers, the Sarpino’s best sellers guide picks the pizzas regulars keep ordering.

Can you still order a discontinued Sarpino’s item anywhere?

Not through Sarpino’s Singapore as far as we can tell. None of these eight items appears on the current Singapore menu, and no outlet listing we checked still carries them by name. Old delivery app listings can lag behind the real menu, so a name showing up on a third party app doesn’t mean the kitchen still makes it. Your best move is to call the outlet on 6636 3636 and ask by name before you order, since staff will know if a past item is still possible as a custom build.

A custom build is your real fallback. Sarpino’s lets you build your own pizza, so you can ask for the closest base and toppings, like a Teriyaki Chicken base with extra chicken for a Satay Chicken fan, or a New York Deli with extra beef sausage for a Godfather fan. It won’t taste identical, but it’s closer than ordering a random pizza and hoping. And if a discontinued favourite does return as a special, it will show up on the current menu first, so check there before you visit.

Sarpino’s discontinued menu items FAQ

Straight answers on the questions readers ask most about Sarpino’s discontinued menu items.